Harm Reduction Advocates Lead Charter Challenge to Save Supervised Consumption Sites

By Fred Alvarado
Fred is a community journalist with FOCUS MEDIA ARTS CENTRE

Harm reduction advocates gathered together just outside 330 University Avenue as an Ontario court began hearing a charter challenge against the province’s plan to shut down 10 supervised consumption sites by April 1, 2025. Among the threatened locations is the Regent Park Community Health Centre—a vital resource that has prevented countless overdoses and saved lives.

The legal challenge, brought forward by a neighbourhood group and two individuals who use these services, argues that the province’s plan violates the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, specifically the right to life, liberty, and security of the person. Experts warn that closing these sites in the midst of a toxic drug crisis will disproportionately harm marginalized communities in Downtown East Toronto.

Mskwaasin Agnew, an Indigenous harm reduction advocate, called the closures “racist,” emphasizing that they ignore clear evidence showing how these sites foster safer environments and offer critical support. “Many of the people I see are from my own urban Indigenous community,” she said. “I see firsthand how my own people are disproportionately impacted by this toxic drug supply.”

Longtime harm reduction leader Zoe Dodd also condemned the government's approach, calling it “shameful” and urging continued community resistance. “This is not about treatment or not treatment. This is about care, love, and a place to be safe from a toxic drug crisis that’s killing people.”

As the court battle continues, advocates are clear: this is not just a legal issue—lives are on the line.